Athlete of the Year
Ed Seiferling
Most Outstanding Male Athlete
| NAME | YEAR |
| Richard Mendonca IV | 2023 |
| Elias Castro | 2022 |
| Joseph Filippini | 2021 |
| Eduardo Guillen | 2020 |
| Lionardo Ruiz | 2019 |
| James McClain | 2018 |
| Andres Sandoval | 2017 |
| Kristopher "KC" Kranich | 2016 |
| Clint Schallberger | 2015 |
| Kelse Depauli-Wiltse | 2014 |
| Jakob Schallberger | 2013 |
| Ryan Rogero | 2012 |
| Andrew Richards | 2011 |
| Michael Hernandez | 2010 |
| Calvin Watt | 2009 |
| Michael Sandoval | 2008 |
| Rico Altimarano | 2007 |
| Jordan Lawley | 2006 |
| Scott Gaines | 2005 |
| Andrew Drake | 2004 |
| Robert Caffese/Sean Dryden | 2003 |
| Nathaniel Malm | 2002 |
| Chuck Booz | 2001 |
| Louis Franklin | 2000 |
| Phouthai Keoveunxay | 1999 |
| Matt Paz | 1998 |
| George Hernandez/Todd Snider | 1997 |
| Jerry Trafton | 1996 |
| Mike Korolyk | 1995 |
| David Reiswig | 1994 |
| Mike Powell/Joel Griffits | 1993 |
| J.J. Chandler | 1992 |
| Eddie Brooks | 1991 |
| Chris Terry | 1990 |
| Billy Griffits | 1989 |
| Yonnie Jackson/Chris Humbert | 1988 |
| Lamar Mitchell | 1987 |
| Craig Straub | 1986 |
| Scott Graddy | 1985 |
| Robert Lewis | 1984 |
| Bruce Thompson | 1983 |
| Brad Leabo | 1982 |
| Rich Anema | 1981 |
| Dalton Duval | 1980 |
| Rick Gaines | 1979 |
| Myron Kiriu | 1978 |
| Jim Brusa | 1977 |
| Randy Correia | 1976 |
| Dave Eisenbeis | 1975 |
| Richard Willis | 1974 |
| Steven Burke | 1973 |
Joanne Katanic
Most Outstanding Female Athlete
| NAME | YEAR |
| Lily Mogler | 2023 |
| Madison Covey-Taylor | 2022 |
| Kali Anema | 2021 |
| Kayly Pau | 2020 |
| Nicole Iturraran | 2019 |
| Jazmin Ruiz | 2018 |
| Madisen Bozovich | 2017 |
| Alexis Cavero | 2017 |
| Julia Coon | 2016 |
| Katie Lopez | 2015 |
| Emily Sousa | 2014 |
| Bailey Smith | 2013 |
| Mary Griffith | 2012 |
| Nicole Buzo | 2011 |
| Katelyne Herrington | 2010 |
| Heather Buzo | 2009 |
| Anne Heberle | 2008 |
| Geneya Terlouw | 2007 |
| Kate Casey | 2006 |
| Sara Watt | 2005 |
| Serena Hubbard | 2004 |
| Hilary Hirzel | 2003 |
| Kara Cockerill | 2002 |
| Melissa Fehn | 2001 |
| Kristina Hieb | 2000 |
| Lindsay Thomas | 1999 |
| Leah Jones | 1998 |
| Jamie Aarons | 1997 |
| Elissa Keszler | 1996 |
| Hilary Hodges | 1995 |
| Mara Formosa | 1994 |
| Stephanie Alber | 1993 |
| Nicole Walker/Dana Black | 1992 |
| Jamie King | 1991 |
| Melinda Daniels/La Nia Brice | 1990 |
| Cathy Charpentier | 1989 |
| Kristen Nieland | 1988 |
| Kirsten George | 1987 |
| Shelly Kilby | 1986 |
| Grete Kegel | 1985 |
| Genetta Adams | 1984 |
| Susan Friedberger | 1983 |
| Jackie Desanti | 1982 |
| Shelly Pfeifer | 1981 |
| Chris Bertsch | 1980 |
| Linda Mizener | 1979 |
| Annette Modavi | 1978 |
| Evette Freggiard | 1977 |
| Kathi Watanabe | 1976 |